What Kind of FOO am I?

by Andrew McAfee on June 18, 2012

A little while back I put borrowed camping gear (thanks, Steve and Lee!) into a rental car and drove from San Francisco to Sebastopol to pitch my tent at FOO Camp, Tim O’Reilly’s annual jamboree of those-doing-cool-things-with-technology.

FOO (which stands for ‘friends of O’Reilly’) is a free, invitation-only unconference, and Tim and his colleagues at O’Reilly media are amazing hosts. There were delicious food and beverages, wifi and meeting rooms, showers and towels, and every other form of hospitality appropriate to the occasion.

FOO Camp 2012 sessions

My highlights included:

  • Listening to Andrew Ng and Peter Norvig describe their MOOCs – Massive, open, online courses — to teach all comers online about artificial intelligence. MOOCs are one of the innovations that will transform / disrupt the educational system in the coming years.
  • Learning about automated writing from Narrative Science’s Kris Hammond. Narrative Science can take a body of data (e.g. the stats from a baseball game) and generate from it individualized prose with varying angles and language. Because I assure you that Red Sox and Yankee fans do not want to read anything like the same story about the same game.
  • Conducting a session with Etsy’s Juliet Gorman and FutureAdvisor’s Bo Lu about the future of jobs and work in an increasingly digital economy. Juliet’s company uses technology to increase the amont of labor by giving craftspeople markets for their products. Bo’s uses tech to remove labor by automating the work of a financial advisor.
  • Having endless hallway, mealtime, and late-night conversations with ridiculously interesting and accomplished people. I wonder if many other people there felt like they were an admissions mistake. I sure did.

The legendary columnist Murray Kempton wrote that he loved New York because it “happens to be the only city under the eye of God where the librettist for Don Giovanni could find his closest friend in the author of “The Night Before Christmas.” Well, FOO Camp is the only place I’ve been where you wind up hanging out midmorning with the Obama campaign’s CTO, the guy at Google responsible for monitoring online repression and attempts to shut off the Internet around the world, one of the world’s leading competitive data scientists, and the guy who monetized Lolcats.

I hope I do enough interesting things in the next year to be invited back. Thanks, Tim and the rest of the O’Reilly gang; you put on a great Geekstock.

{ 2 comments }

In my last post, which recapped a fascinating lunch I had with a bunch of economists and AI researchers at MIT, I wrote

Computers are getting bigger and faster, but not ‘smarter’ in any human sense of the word. Artificial intelligence bears very little relationship to the human variety, and the two are not going to merge. One of the AI researchers referred to the idea of the Singularity as a ‘category mistake,’ which is a great academic insult.

A couple people asked for more details about this ‘category mistake,’ so I went back and reviewed my notes from the meeting. Here’s an edited, imperfect transcript of what one of the attendees said (I’ll follow the Chatham House rule)

There’s a type error there, which is conflating FLOPS with intelligence. [Some Singularity advocates] are just plotting FLOPS against brain size, saying they cross in 2035 or whenever and therefore…  and that’s just obviously a mistake. There’s something missing there. [Intelligence is] not just counting cycles

The AI professionals were pretty adamant that faster machines were not automatically smarter machines, and that all the work they were doing to accomplish amazing feats like speech recognition, automatic translation, robot mobility and manipulation, driverless driving, and so on was not causing computers to become any more human.

To which I can only say, whew!

{ 6 comments }

Real Insights about Artificial Intelligence

May 7, 2012

A little while back Frank Levy, an MIT economist whose work I’ve drawn on a lot, and Seth Teller and John Leonard of the Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Lab (CSAIL) came to an important realization: MIT is home to both a set of people exploring the economic implications of cutting-edge technologies like AI, and [...]

Read the full article →

Talk With Me About All Things Digital on May 3 at 2 pm EDT

May 2, 2012

A little while back I sat down with Martha Mangelsdorf, the editorial director of MIT Sloan Management Review, to talk about digital business. We covered the Cloud; Big Data; Enterprise 2.0; technology, skills, and jobs; and lots else. Martha asked great questions; I hope my answers were in the same league. SMR will air a [...]

Read the full article →

The MIT of Entrepreneurship Studies

April 30, 2012

… is actually a new course being offered to MIT students this summer. I just learned from Bill Aulet, the Managing Director of the Martin Trust Center for MIT Entrepreneurship, about a great new initiative getting started at the Institute this summer exclusively available to its students and 2012 grads. It’s called the Founder Skills [...]

Read the full article →

Where the Jobs Aren’t for New Grads

April 23, 2012

I was reading an otherwise really good story about education and employment at Yahoo! news when I came across the following sentence: Most job openings are in professions such as retail sales, fast food and truck driving, jobs which aren’t easily replaced by computers. Actually, they are, or soon will be. We might need human [...]

Read the full article →

How to Introduce Autonomous Cars Without Cooking the Planet

April 18, 2012

Many of us can’t wait for autonomous cars, and would pay a lot to have one and be freed up from the hassles of driving. State governments should welcome autonomous cars, too. As Sebastian Thrum convincingly argues, they’ll be safer than human-piloted ones. And they’ll pretty clearly lead to better traffic flow (because they can [...]

Read the full article →

Free and Cheaper: The World’s Best News

April 17, 2012

The speed with which our economies and societies are digitizing continues to astonish. I think Marc Andreesen was only about one third right when he wrote recently that “software is eating the world.” Data and devices are, too. The growth in hardware, software, and data is interdependent, complementary, and self-reinforcing, and emphasizing only one trend misses [...]

Read the full article →

Apple and Philippe Starck? I Don’t See It.

April 13, 2012

According to PCMag.com, Philippe Starck said in a french radio interview that he’s working with Apple on a “revolutionary” new product to be unveiled within a year. The speculation is that they’re collaborating on TVs, since Starck has designed them before. I have trouble believing that these two design giants are really working together; it [...]

Read the full article →

Robots are the Talk of the Nation Today

April 4, 2012

The cool news: I’m going to be on NPR’s Talk of the Nation today at 3 pm Boston Time talking about technology, the economy, and jobs. The not-so-cool news: it appears that Boston’s WBUR only carries the first hour of the show, from 2-3. So the hometown audience will have to stream it, find another [...]

Read the full article →